Four-point validation:
1. COMPLETENESS ✅ PASS
- All 6 Button states covered
- All 7 Input states covered
- All 10 Select states covered
- All 7 Card states covered
2. ORTHOGONALITY 🟡 PASS WITH NOTES
- 3 minor overlaps identified (surface.raised vs overlay, text.secondary vs muted, action.disabled vs text.muted)
- All resolved by distinct use cases
- 1 ambiguity noted (brand vs action), documented in contracts
3. MINIMALITY 🟡 PASS WITH NOTES
- 9 unused tokens identified
- All justified: needed for upcoming components (Modal, Link, Alert) or dark mode
- No tokens should be removed
4. STABILITY ✅ PASS
- Modal: 0 new tokens needed
- Navigation: 0 new tokens needed
- Table: 0 new tokens needed
- Map Panel: 0 new tokens needed
VERDICT: APPROVE with minor notes. Semantic Color System is stable enough to freeze.
Action items:
1. Freeze Semantic Color System v1.0
2. Update Input, Select, Card to semantic aliases (raise to ~80%)
3. Create Foundation Freeze milestone
4. Proceed with Modal, Navigation, Table, Map Panel
Bernt
325a872fdb